Introduction

Imagine you have a unique vision for a piece of jewelry — something that perfectly captures your personal style or commemorates a special moment in your life. But turning this vision into reality can be daunting. Where do you start? Who can help bring your design to life with the care and quality it deserves?

Custom jewelry includes options like choice of metal, as shown in this rubellite ring.

The challenge lies in finding a brand that not only sells custom jewelry but also aligns with your expectations for quality, craftsmanship, and customer service. With so many options available, how do you choose the right one to trust with something so personal and important?

This article is your guide to navigating the world of custom jewelry brands. We’ll explore which specialize in creating bespoke pieces, what to expect during the design process, and how to ensure your finished piece is everything you dreamed it would be. Whether you’re looking to design a stunning engagement ring or a unique necklace that tells your story, finding the right brand is the first step to turning your jewelry dreams into reality.

Table of Contents

Best Custom Jewelry Websites

When you’re looking for custom jewelry, it’s important to choose a brand that is known for making high-quality pieces. Here are some of the top brands that specialize in turning your unique ideas into beautiful jewelry.

A note: These are the opinions of the editor, and do not reflect those of Shop LC or included brands. Neither the author nor Shop LC will receive compensation for including these brands. It is our heartfelt desire to help readers make the most informed jewelry buying decisions possible.

Kissyan Jewelry

Founded in 2015, Kissyan Jewelry offers a range of gorgeous name necklaces, as well as a selection of initial rings. Kissyan prioritizes sustainability, using recycled metals to reduce environmental impact and promote a healthier planet.

Woman wearing "Sophia" custom name necklace.
Photo credit: Kissyan Jewelry

As a starter piece, we recommend the Custom Name Necklace with Shining Birthstone. It’s an affordable entry-level piece that frankly looks great. Each option, from base to finish to accent stone is customizable, ensuring you can stay within your budget while designing a great piece of jewelry.

Mignon & Mignon

Mignon and Mignon specializes in cute, delicate, and elegant jewelry. Their offering include hand-stamped bar charms, bracelet, and necklaces that come in a variety of finishes including gold, rose-gold, and silver. 

Closeup view of woman wearing custom pet necklace.
Photo credit: Mignon & Mignon

A stand out option from this brand is that they not only have customized jewelry for humans, but they also offer a range of pet jewelry for commemorating your fur baby! As more of us choose to rescue animals in need, it’s important that we recognize those making this loving decision.

UMAGICBOX

Since 2007, UMAGICBOX has been offering handmade custom jewelry and shipping to over 50 countries. The brand offers a range of personalization options in their offerings, ranging from metal choice to stone selection.

Closeup view of monogram cufflinks.
Photo credit: UMAGICBOX

A standout option for me was the customizable cufflinks. While cufflinks have largely fallen out of style for men, there are those (like your humble editor) who still enjoy wearing them. It’s nice when you come across selections beyond base metals and the same boring designs.

MOMOL Jewelry

MOMOL Jewelry offers a nice selection of initial jewelry in a common selection of metals and finishes. What makes them a top selection for me is the no-fuss price points – Shop LC customers will love these too.

Closeup view of sideways "A" initial necklace.
Photo credit: MOMOL Jewelry

My top pick are the sideways initials necklaces. These have been trending for a moment, and we love how the askew lettering offers a jaunty take on the classic initial pendant necklace.

Fissen Jewelry

Discover a range of delicate and minimalist initial jewelry with Fissen Jewelry. Though maximalism and chunky designs are on the rise, stalwarts like Fissen continue offering reliable staples of dainty and feminine design.

Closeup view of woman wearing dainty heart pendant with stamped initial.
Photo credit: Fissen Jewelry

With very affordable options across the board, my pick is the plated heart initial pendant. It’s a great starter piece if you have children like my daughter who are discovering themselves through jewelry and fashion.

U7 Jewelry

Bringing an eclectic selection of personalized selections, U7 Jewelry brings forward an impressive selection. We were impressed with their dedication to industry compliance and setting themselves to the highest standards.

Gold heart picture locket cross section, showing off its various features.
Photo credit: U7 Jewelry

What delighted me while reviewing their site was the wide range of picture jewelry and lockets they make available. It’s not often that you find lockets, let alone such a wide range of options for personalization.

Glimmerst

Offering an enticing array of personalized jewelry, Glimmerst provides a sharp focus on initial pieces. Most are made of stainless steel with a gold plating, providing a strong finish that will hold up to daily wear and tear.

Smiling woman wearing gold plated birth year necklace.
Photo credit: Glimmerst

We love the birth year necklace, an offering we haven’t yet come across when perusing the offerings of other sellers. Simply select from your preferred finish and lock in the birth year and you’re good to go!

MyNameNecklace

If you’re ready for something a bit more luxe, then I think we have the perfection option for you. MyNameNecklace has a collection of personalized name necklaces that allow you to express yourself in a way that’s truly one-of-a-kind.

Closeup view of a woman in a red dress wearing an infinity name necklace.
Photo credit: MyNameNecklace

In my opinion, a standout choice from their offerings is the infinity name necklace. It’s a cool and unique design I haven’t yet seen elsewhere, and would make for a great self purchase or gift.

PicturesOnGold.com

Interested in meaningful keepsakes that last? PicturesOnGold.com creates lasting photo lockets and photo jewelry keepsakes using only the finest 14k gold, white gold and sterling silver.

Closeup view of woman wearing Texas Tech name necklace.
Photo credit: PicturesOnGold.com

We were impressed with the wide selection available, including options like sports jewelry and religious jewelry. Both are often overlooked options when it comes to offering a truly customized experience.

Wellike Jewelry

Something we haven’t yet delved into are more colorful options. That’s where Wellike Jewelry comes in. This seller offers a plethora of fun and whimsical – and most importantly, colorful – jewelry.

Close up view of young woman wearing colorful layered necklaces.
Photo credit: Wellike Jewelry

My standout choice is their signature colorful beaded initial choker necklace. Stainless steel construction ensures an option that will last, while the gold plating provides the look of luxury that you’ll love.

AGISLONE

Like many sellers, AGISLONE offers and delightful range of elegant personalized jewelry. However, Shop LC readers crave value, and this offered in spades with their curated selection of items.

AGISLONE personalized heart pendant.
Photo credit: AGISLONE

I was immediately drawn to their unique personalized heart necklace. Fitting two names and two birthstones, it makes for an excellent birthday gift, anniversary present, or Mother’s Day gift.

MEVECCO

Offering a range of fine gold jewelry, MEVECCO is another on my list of top sellers. They endeavor to offer women of all types small treasures to help you enjoy every moment of life.

Closeup view of young woman wearing gold initial earrings.
Photo credit: Mevecco

One of my favorite pieces from their many offerings are the initial huggie earrings. It’s a unique option we don’t often get to see. Both fun and affordable, it’s an easy addition to most jewelry collections.

M MOOHAM

Another entry into the gold-plated brass category, M MOOHAM provides a reliable selection of personalized staples. Their fun and affordable product range will suit all budgets, but especially those of us who love to save!

Silver initial heart pendant on white silky background.
Photo credit: M MOOHAM

My recommendation has to be their initial heart pendant necklace. It’s such a timeless piece, and I think it’s one that you’ll love wearing day-to-day as a signature selection from your jewelry collection.

GoldChic Jewelry

Like many others, GoldChic Jewelry is available through Amazon, peddling a unique assortment of jewelry wares that are sure to catch your eye.

Custom gold necklace on white background.
Photo credit: GoldChic Jewelry

Our standout selection has to be the gold-plated stainless steel necklace. While most options reviewed so far use brass, stainless steel is a great consideration for those with more active lifestyles or those of use that be harder on our jewelry.

Shop LC

Last, but certainly not least, comes Shop LC. You know us, you love us and our Purpose of Delivering Joy. With every purchase providing a meal to a child in need, you’re giving two gifts when you choose us as your jewelry destination – for you or your loved one and a hungry child in the US or India.

Luxoro 14K White Gold Premium Ethiopian Welo Opal and G-H I1-I2 Diamond Ring 4 Grams 1.30 ctw

It was a tough decision to narrow down my favorite custom jewelry piece from Shop LC. After all, as editor, I’m reviewing these pieces every day! However, when it comes do it, I have to go with this LUXORO opal ring. Opal is one of my favorite gems, as well as my partner’s birthstone. It’s a piece I’d love to buy for her (in white gold, her favorite of course).

These brands not only provide beautiful jewelry but also make sure every piece is made with care and precision. Choosing any of these brands means you’re in good hands, and you’ll end up with a piece of jewelry that’s as unique as you are.

Conclusion

Choosing the right brand for custom jewelry means embarking on a creative journey to bring your unique vision to life. The brands highlighted in this article, represent the pinnacle of craftsmanship and customer service. Each offers a distinct process and array of options that cater to your personal taste and design preferences.

As you consider which custom jewelry brands are your favorites, think about the materials, design flexibility, and the level of involvement you desire in the creation process. These factors are crucial in ensuring that the final piece not only meets but exceeds your expectations, providing you with a timeless token of personal expression.

Embarking on this path with a trusted brand not only guarantees a beautiful and high-quality result but also ensures a memorable and enjoyable experience. Whether for a special occasion or to add a unique piece to your collection, the perfect custom jewelry piece awaits with the right brand partnership.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 4.9 / 5. Vote count: 325

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?